Hello everyone! I promised I would be back soon, didn’t I? I also promised a review of a very popular book this year. That is what I present to you today. Now, initially, I wasn’t super keen on reading Yesteryear. I wasn’t super excited, but I was intrigued. Lo and behold, I found a brand new copy at a secondhand bookstore. For eight dollars, I will happily check out the hottest new release. With that being said, it’s finally time for me to give my two cents on Yesteryear.
Content Warning: Domestic Violence, Child Abuse and Neglect, Sexual Abuse, Explicit Language, Internalized Misogyny, Discussions of Bigotry, Disturbing Imagery, Explicit Sexual Content, Religious Trauma, Substance Abuse, Postpartum Depression
Natalie Heller Mills has made perfection her business. To her Instagram followers, she effortlessly manages her growing family and successful farm. Natalie, though, knows she is living a lie. The cracks are starting to appear, but she is confident that she can smooth over these wrinkles and continue to be America’s favorite “trad wife.” One day, Natalie wakes up in a home that isn’t hers with people she doesn’t know. It’s also 1855. Natalie is now faced with a harsh new reality where every day is a fight to survive. It’s only a matter of time before she finds out what is really happening, and she will have to face some dark truths.
I will be honest: I have mixed feelings about Yesteryear. I will be nice, though, before I present my criticisms. First of all, I enjoyed the writing and the narrative voice. Burke’s choice to have Natalie as the POV character makes this novel all the more immersive. It is rather entertaining to have such an unlikeable, yet compelling, main character. I also felt that Burke provided a thorough examination of the “trad wife influencer” lifestyle. It wasn’t just about that, though. Burke examines conservative spheres and the pitfalls that come with them, like relying on fear-mongering and blind obedience. There was also plenty said about Christian Nationalism, which I found fascinating. With all of that being said, Yesteryear wasn’t exactly eye-opening. This novel might be a little too timely. It is hard to say if this will have any cultural relevance in the next five years. More and more media is starting to cover the downfall of conservatism, so Yesteryear is not wholly unique. The same can be said for books about social media influencers. I did, however, find myself pleasantly surprised by how the novel resolved. That, however, is not for me to reveal. With all of this being said, I am going to recommend Yesteryear because it is certainly compelling and brutal in its own unique ways.

Leave a Reply